Convenience of the Employer: Understanding and Compliance for Non-Resident Employees
What is the "Convenience of the Employer" Rule?
The "Convenience of the Employer" rule determines whether non-resident employees (those who live outside New York State) must pay New York State income taxes or the taxes of their home state. This rule is crucial for ensuring proper tax withholding and compliance with state laws.
Why is This Important?
Properly determining the correct state for income tax withholding ensures compliance with tax laws and helps avoid potential penalties, audits, and fines. Both employers and employees benefit from understanding and correctly applying this rule.
Primary Factor
The first step in determining tax obligations is to assess the primary factor:
Does the employee maintain a home office in another state near special facilities unavailable at or near your New York office?
Yes: The employee is not subject to New York income taxes.
No: Proceed to evaluate secondary and other factors.
Convenience of the Employer Test
To further determine tax obligations, evaluate the secondary and other factors.
Secondary Factors (Must meet at least 4):
The home office is a requirement or condition of employment.
The employer has a bona fide business purpose for the home office.
Core duties are performed at the home office.
Regular meetings with clients, patients, or customers occur at the home office.
The employer does not provide designated office space at a regular place of business.
The employer reimburses home office expenses.
Other Factors (Must meet at least 3):
Separate telephone line and listing for the home office.
Home office address and phone number are on business letterhead or business cards.
Home office is used exclusively for employer's business.
Supply of products or samples are kept at the home office.
Business records are stored in the home office.
Home office has a business sign.
Home office is identified in advertising as a place of business.
Home office is covered by business insurance.
Federal income tax deduction is claimed for the home office.
The employee is not an officer of the company.
Determining Tax Obligations
If at least 4 Secondary Factors and at least 3 Other Factors are met: The employee is not subject to New York income taxes. Set them up as a work-from-home employee and withhold taxes for their home state.
If not: The employee is considered a telecommuter and is subject to New York income taxes.
Example Scenario
John, the Employee:
Maintains a home office in New Jersey (no special facilities needed).
Core duties performed at home.
Regularly meets clients at home.
No designated office space in NY.
Employer reimburses home office expenses.
Separate phone line for home office.
Home office listed on business cards.
Home office used exclusively for work.
John checks off:
4 Secondary Factors.
3 Other Factors.
Outcome: John is not subject to New York income taxes. Taxes will be withheld for New Jersey.
Steps to Compliance
Evaluate Factors: Carefully review and check applicable secondary and other factors.
Complete the Form: Ensure all required sections are filled out accurately.
Submit the Form: Provide the completed form to the employer for proper tax withholding setup.
Need Assistance?
If you have any questions or need further assistance, we highly recommend consulting with your legal, tax, or financial advisor. Accurately completing the "Convenience of the Employer" form is crucial for compliance and avoiding potential issues.
Want to find out if a PEO is right for you, let us help you.